loader image

The Differences Between Part-Time and Live-In Caregivers: 8 Factors To Remember

Nov 16, 2022

Following hospitalization, families may require short-term aged care assistance if the primary caregiver is overburdened with other responsibilities or just needs a break. In Singapore, there are numerous long-term care facilities, including nursing homes and daycare centers, which deliver quality care, but occasionally family members struggle to locate appropriate short-term care services.

Many people, especially the elderly or those who live independently, run the danger of being readmitted to the hospital if they don’t receive the right elderly care and assistance at home after being discharged. Welfare and recovery are greatly aided by having the right caregiving services, a comfortable home environment, adequate care support, and caregivers who are competent and well-informed.

1. What Is the Type of Employment and Housing Conditions?

Generally, the originating country must be one of those recognized by MOM in order for a foreign live-in caregiver to be recruited as a foreign domestic worker (FDW), which the  Philippines, Myanmar, and Indonesia constitute widely accepted nations. Also, at the time of applying, the live-in caregiver’s age must fall between 23 and 50.

The contrary is true in Singapore, where a part-time, live-out caregiver is a native, private caregiver who has been hired on an hourly-rated premise and is typically a Singaporean or Permanent Resident. The caregiver, who is normally a freelancer, will make periodic visits to the care recipient’s residence to provide caregiving shifts, usually lasting no more than 12 hours at a time. In this setup, no caregiver will be residing in the care recipient’s household.

2. What Is the Extent of Caregiving Services Needed?

Part-time and live-in caregivers both serve assistance with activities of daily living, which is a comparable aspect of caregiving. More specialized care, including nasogastric tube feeding, might be something they can offer. If they have prior expertise in providing such treatment, it will depend on what they can do.

The installation of a nasogastric tube (NGT) or an implantable urinary catheter are cases of interventional procedures that caregivers are prohibited from performing. Instead, a  qualified healthcare provider, such as a doctor, nurse practitioner, or registered nurse, must perform these.

3. Is a Caregiver Obligated to Perform Housework?

In addition to providing care, a live-in caregiver assists with housekeeping, buying groceries, cleaning the care recipient’s bedroom, and cooking for them. Also, the live-in caregiver could also help with some chores for other residents of the household, such as cooking and preparing meals for another family member who lives there.

Household chores, including cooking, cleaning, and laundry, are outside the purview of part-time caregivers’ employment. They have a limited range of light housekeeping abilities, like making the care recipient’s bed and cleaning the dishes after mealtime.

4. How Long Is the Waiting Period Before the Caregiver Starts Working?

When a work visa is granted, usually within a few days to a week of filing an application with MOM, a caregiver who is already residing in Singapore can begin working with the family. Depending on the method followed by each agency, the processing period for caregivers who live abroad can take anywhere from 2 weeks to 8 weeks.

It is possible to hire part-time caregivers as needed, and a few days’ notice is usually recommended by agencies. But granted that there are caregivers available and it is on-demand basis, unscheduled shifts can also be organized. Being independent contractors, the nearby caregivers could have a little free time in between jobs, thus, this is a possibility.

home caregiving grant

5. What Are the Living Arrangements Available for the Caregivers?

The families must agree to an employment contract before hiring a live-in caregiver. Normally, the work contract specifies that the caregiver will work for the employer throughout the timeframe indicated in the work permit, which is typically two years. The termination process will adhere to the terms of the employment contract in the event that either the employer or the live-in caregiver decides to not proceed with the contract.

6. How Many Languages Does the Caregiver Know?

Families can normally anticipate that local caregivers will be able to converse with their senior loved ones in their native dialects. Communication could or might not be a problem for live-in caregivers from other nations. They might be fluent in English if they are Filipino caregivers. Typically, Indonesian caregivers will have little trouble conversing with senior Malay speakers.

Prior to traveling to Singapore, new caregivers will frequently have received some education in basic English. Family members should look for caregivers with professional experience in Singapore, Hong Kong, or Taiwan if speech is a priority for them. In general, caregivers with experience in Singapore speak English competently.

7. What to Consider for the Caregivers’ Experience, Training, or Certifications?

To be a competent caregiver, one must possess several necessary abilities. To help caregivers acquire the skills and information they need to deliver the finest care, agencies hold intensive training sessions and seminars. The said training covers dealing with stress, developing patience, and all facets of helping senior citizens.

Families who choose to hire a live-in caregiver more than a domestic helper frequently do so due to their education, experience, or license. The native, part-time caregivers are often trained internally by their different agencies in Singapore. Each agency has a different training program and time frame for the native caregiver.

8. How Much Does Hiring Caregiving Services Cost?

In addition to working from home, the live-in caregiver is compensated with a  monthly salary payment from the employer. Contingent on the caregiver’s training and experience, the baseline monthly pay might range from $580 to $1000. The employer is obligated to cover the live-in caregiver’s living expenses, medical costs, and wages in Singapore in addition to these other costs, and a $60 monthly FDW levy is applied to families with older citizens.

Meanwhile, families often have the option of paying a premium for a native certified nurse or a reduced cost for a qualified local caregiver for part-time care. Such local caregivers often cost families $20 an hour, while licensed nurses typically cost $24 per hour per patient. Additionally, a 12-hour shift from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. would cost roughly $240 per day for a qualified local caregiver.

Live-in or Live-Out Caregiver: Which Is the Better Choice?

By hiring a live-in caregiver, the elderly patient is guaranteed continuous attention from the same caregiver. While it is true if a live-in caregiver is recruited, it might not be the same if the family members choose part-time caregivers.

Whenever households hire a live-in caregiver, they tend to take over as the primary caregiver. There is no doubt that they will be in charge of the majority of the caregiving duties for their loved ones. Family members may also anticipate that a small number of local, Part-time caregivers will be in charge of managing the care of their aging loved ones when they hire their services. Although, it can be challenging to hold a specific caregiver responsible when problems develop.

In order to keep costs down, families usually hire a live-in caregiver to take care of the care recipients on a long-term basis, supplemented when necessary by local part-time and temporary caregivers. Households in Singapore also have access to a wide range of government grants and subsidies, including the Home Caregiving Grant (HCG), if additional financial resources are required.

Experience Top-Notch Caregiving Services With Retire Genie

Giving your elderly loved one who is recovering the level of care they need may become challenging without your constant presence. Luckily, there are institutions designed specifically to help families in this situation. Essentially, a live-in or part-time caregiver can provide your loved one with in-home care services in the comfort of their own home for however long is required. In a way, your elderly loved ones can continue to live a healthy and happy life with the help of customized home care and a senior caregiver from Retire Genie.

Recent Articles: 

Join Waitlist We will inform you when the product arrives in stock. Please leave your valid email address below.